Methodological challenges for the large N study of local participatory experiences: combining methods and databases

Galais Gonzàlez, Carolina; Font, Joan; Alarcón, Pau; Sesma, Dolores

doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/ris.2012.04.04

Methodological challenges for the large N study of local participatory experiences: combining methods and databases

License

Citation

Galais C, Font J, Alarcón P, Sesma D. Methodological challenges for the large N study of local participatory experiences: combining methods and databases. Rev Int Sociol. 2012 Dec;70(2):65-87. DOI: 10.3989/ris.2012.04.04

Abstract

In this article we analyse the effects of different data collection strategies in the study of local participatory experiences in a region of Spain (Andalusia). We examine the divergences and similarities between the data collected using different methods, as well as the implications for the reliability of the data. We have collected participatory experiences through two parallel processes: a survey of municipalities and web content mining. The survey of municipalities used two complementary strategies: an online questionnaire and a CATI follow-up for those municipalities that had not answered our first online contact attempt. Both processes (survey and data mining) were applied to the same sample of municipalities, but provided significantly different images of the characteristics of Andalusia’s participatory landscape. The goal of this work is to discuss the different types of biases introduced by each data collection procedure and their implications for substantive analyses.