Why can the brain (and not a computer) make sense of the liar paradox?

Fraser, Patrick; Solé Vicente, Ricard, 1962-; Cuevas, Gemma de las

doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fevo.2021.802300

Why can the brain (and not a computer) make sense of the liar paradox?

License

Citation

Fraser P, Solé R, De las Cuevas G. Why can the brain (and not a computer) make sense of the liar paradox? Front Ecol Evol. 2021;9:802300. DOI: 10.3389/fevo.2021.802300

Abstract

Ordinary computing machines prohibit self-reference because it leads to logical inconsistencies and undecidability. In contrast, the human mind can understand self-referential statements without necessitating physically impossible brain states. Why can the brain make sense of self-reference? Here, we address this question by defining the Strange Loop Model, which features causal feedback between two brain modules, and circumvents the paradoxes of self-reference and negation by unfolding the inconsistency in time. We also argue that the metastable dynamics of the brain inhibit and terminate unhalting inferences. Finally, we show that the representation of logical inconsistencies in the Strange Loop Model leads to causal incongruence between brain subsystems in Integrated Information Theory.