Remembering as the same

Verdejo Aparicio, Víctor Martín

doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11229-024-04720-x

Remembering as the same

Citation

Verdejo VM. Remembering as the same. Synthese. 2024;204:104. DOI: 10.1007/s11229-024-04720-x

Abstract

One may not only represent the same objects of one’s past, but also represent them as the same objects across time. I call this phenomenon “Remembering as the Same” (RaS). In this article, I aim to bring out the connection between the simulationist model of cognitive memory and this underexplored aspect of memory experience. I shall suggest that, unlike the causalist contender, the simulationist is in an advantageous position to properly capture RaS, especially when subjects represent past objects as the same in cross-temporal trains of thought that are also future-oriented. In the course of defending this claim, I will highlight the significance of RaS in the study of memory and cross-temporal reference, critically examine the resources available to causalist approaches, and reject too simplistic incorporations of RaS within the simulationist framework.